Born just after the presidential campaign of Tippecanoe and Tyler, too,
Tenney was named after American president William Henry Harrison. A deacon in the Congregational Church in Linebrook, Massachusetts, he edited or was associate editor of over 30 books, and contributed to hundreds more. His works include:
- American Male Choir
- Golden Sunbeams, with Daniel Hodges (Lee and Shepard, 1876)
- Temperance Jewels, with Elisha Hoffman (Boston, Massachusetts: Oliver Ditson & Company, 1879)
- Bells of Victory, with Elisha Hoffman (Boston, Massachusetts: Oliver Ditson & Company, 1888)
- Gems of Gospel Song
- Sharon’s Dewy Rose
- Songs of Faith
- Shining Light
- Songs of Joy
- Sparkling and Bright
- Spiritual Songs, Nos. 1 and 2
- Sweet Fields of Eden
- The Beacon Light
- The Singing School Banner
- The Anthem Offering
- The American Anthem Book
- The Crown of Praise