Born: October 17, 1858, Dover, Missouri.
Died: April 7, 1911, Lexington, Kentucky.
Buried: Lexington Cemetery, Lexington, Kentucky.
McGarvey was the son of John William McGarvey, Sr., and Otwayanna Frances Hix, and husband of Fanny Taylor. His father was a minister like his son, with whom he is often confused.
John Jr. served as president of the Madison Institute, a ladies’ boarding school in Richmond, Kentucky.