Why should the living complain when punished for their sins?
Lamentations 3:39

Words: John Newton (1725–1807). Appeared in Olney Hymns (London: W. Oliver, 1779), Book 3, number 30, alt. Though published in 1779, the text was written earlier during Newton’s ministry in Olney, and is considered one of his earliest known hymns. Newton wrote the lyrics to fit the tune of his wife Mary’s favorite aria, My Fond Shepherds, from Thomas Arne’s 1754 opera Eliza.
Music: Fremont Adalaski D. Sartwell, 1903 (🔊 pdf nwc).
If you know where to get a good photo of Sartwell (head & shoulders, at least 200×300 pixels),
When my Savior, my Shepherd, is near,
How quickly my sorrows depart!
New beauties around me appear,
New spirits enliven my heart:
His presence gives peace to my soul,
And Satan assaults me in vain;
While my Shepherd his power controls,
I think I no more shall complain.
But alas, what a change do I find,
When my Shepherd withdraws from my sight!
Then my fears all return to my mind,
And my day is soon changed into night:
And the devil his efforts renews
To confound and ensnare me again;
All my pleasing enjoyments I lose,
And can only lament and complain.
By these changes I often pass thro’,
I am taught my own weakness to know;
I am taught what my Shepherd can do,
And how much to His mercy I owe:
It is He who supports me thro’ all,
When I faint He revives me again;
He attends to my prayer when I call,
And He bids me no longer complain.
O then why should I murmur and grieve?
Since my Shepherd is always the same,
And has promised He never will leave
Any soul that confides in His name:
To relieve me from all that I fear,
He was buffeted, tempted, and slain;
And at length He will surely appear,
Tho’ He leaves me awhile to complain.
While I dwell in the enemy’s land,
Can I hope to be always in peace?
’Tis enough that my Shepherd’s at hand,
And that shortly this warfare will cease;
For ere long He will bid me remove
From this region of sorrow and pain,
To abide in His presence above,
And then I no more shall complain.